Skip to content

Bind confirmation identity to what the run reads

An inspection identity bound HEAD, the index, and Git status, so any commit to the default branch between inspection and start invalidated a confirmation. That made proposing an update from an unrelated session hostile in practice while adding no content safety: HEAD says nothing about the bytes adoption reads or writes. Identity now binds the selection, resolved materials, affected bytes and modes, the product-state inventory, and, for discovery-backed runs, the discovery observation. HEAD is recorded in the run for provenance but is not bound. Start still requires a clean tree. The trade-off is that an unrelated commit can sit between inspection and start; if it changes anything the run reads, the bound content changes and the identity with it.

ADR 0012 extends this decision: the identity no longer binds the project root either, which the run records for provenance like HEAD, and ignore inputs are bound by role and content rather than by location.