Skip to content

Leave available updates to the maintainer

Superseded for adopters who opt in by ADR 0026: a caller workflow running the update action proposes every available update through one rolling pull request or issue. Without that opt-in, this decision holds.

What to do with an available update was left to the adopted standards’ own guidance. One standards source therefore made every contextual update a separate tracked work item, and almost every release of that source was contextual. An update with no agent work still became planned work, against the intent that updates never block and add no churn.

The product now owns the update notice: a model-invocable system skill that runs outdated, reinstalls the pinned runtime when it reports CLI_PIN_MISMATCH, and tells the agent which updates are available. The notice states availability only. Without a maintainer’s instruction, the agent mentions the update and continues its current work. Once the maintainer asks for the update, the agent carries it as a change separate from that work. No standards source routes updates, and updateClass stays in the inspection report as information for the reviewer, not as a routing input.

  • Leave the notice to standards sources. Each source would repeat it, and its rules would govern product behavior.
  • A section of adopt-standards. That skill only runs when someone invokes it, so the notice would come only after someone had already chosen to update.
  • A session-start hook. It would work in only one agent.
  • Start every available update by default. Each update needs an inspection and the maintainer’s confirmation, so the maintainer would review work they had not asked for.

A skill description is advisory: an agent may not invoke the notice, and an agent without skill support never sees it. outdated stays the complete interface for a maintainer who wants no agent involved.