Start when nothing is open
Amends ADR 0021 and
ADR 0024. An
agent that ran adopt always needed a second invocation to start: the first
printed an answers-file template, and the run began only once an answers file
named the inspection’s identity, even when no question was open and no change
needed confirmation. With reuse under ADR 0024, an unchanged update still took
that round trip. As settled in decision 2 of the
#281 grilling outcome
and specified in #328,
adopt starts the run in the invocation whose fresh inspection holds all of
these:
- It requires no confirmation.
- Nothing blocks the start, and no
remote-setupanswer isresolve. - No question is open. An answers file, a reused answer, or a default
adoptalready proposes as the answer, the version and the profile, answers a question. A scope draft, or a prefilled proposal an answers file has not carried back, stays open in every mode.
The start binds the identity it just computed and follows the ordinary start
path and its blockers. Its report describes the run as before and carries the
inspection summary, so the agent summarizes it in the handoff afterwards. Git
can undo the uncommitted result. With ADR 0024, an unchanged update is one
adopt --json invocation.
Consequences
Section titled “Consequences”An inspection that requires confirmation keeps the rules of ADR 0021: the
answers file names its identity in confirmation and inspection, and a stale
identity stays missing. Otherwise inspection is never missing and an answer
naming another identity stops nothing. The question stays in the template, so
repo-standards/answers/v1 files keep working.
adopt without an answers file is no longer a read-only preview and can start a
run, so this is a breaking change; inspect is the read-only preview. A terminal
session still asks a person before every start, because human terminal
questions stay human choices.
Considered options
Section titled “Considered options”- Keep the identity round trip. This preserves a review step the agent cannot skip, but for changes Git can restore it adds an invocation with no decision in it.
- Start without asking at a terminal too. This would take a start decision from a person who is present to make it.